Only some are effected and of those individuals only some of the time. We have a wide variety of field service engineers based out of the home office using comcast. The thing is though, that comcast seems to be doing this only in selective markets and only some of the time. I am a Notes/Domino Admin and can confirm the findings that comcast is manipulating the notes traffic on port 1352. It really is a simple question, though: why won’t Comcast tell its own customers what it’s blocking? When you find out that the company is blocking completely legitimate applications and services with no recourse (or even information admitting it), it’s really quite troublesome.įiled Under: bittorrent, cable, gnutella, lotus notes, network neutrality, traffic shaping, transparency Even in the cases where there are, the alternatives often include one other player: a telco like AT&T who seems to be gearing up to do the same thing as Comcast in blocking certain types of content online.
![peerguardian twitch peerguardian twitch](https://static-cdn.jtvnw.net/jtv_user_pictures/482eff2b-37b6-4eef-8295-d53cbda8b390-profile_image-300x300.png)
The only problem is that there often aren’t any alternatives. If people knew that Comcast was arbitrarily cutting off what they could do on their network with no indication (and, actually, actively hiding the fact that they were doing so) many people would look for alternatives.
![peerguardian twitch peerguardian twitch](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/BjXiGyYgELs/maxresdefault.jpg)
Once again, this is the type of thing that wouldn’t happen if there were true competition in the broadband market. Of course, Comcast can do what it wants on its network, but to deny it and not be even remotely transparent about it is pretty questionable (and potentially a violation of FTC rules).
![peerguardian twitch peerguardian twitch](https://static-cdn.jtvnw.net/jtv_user_pictures/62824f50-d5bc-4804-98b9-04fecd2d08c5-profile_image-300x300.png)
The EFF has been running a variety of tests and has found that Comcast appears to send forged reset packets for Gnutella, and it points to someone else who found the same thing for Lotus Notes. However, that’s only because it’s doing similar kinds of blocking on other types of traffic, such as content using Gnutella or even Lotus Notes. Of course, that can mean different things to different people, and as the EFF is discovering, perhaps Comcast is being half-truthful in saying it doesn’t specifically pick on BitTorrent trafffic. Mon, Oct 22nd 2007 07:30am - Mike MasnickĪfter the AP confirmed that Comcast was clearly blocking some aspects of Bittorrent, Comcast continued to issue its oddly worded denial statement about how it doesn’t specifically block access to any application or content.